Trade-In Your Toy Collection at Out The Box Toy Shop

Easy Trade-In Options at Out The Box 
At Out The Box, we’re committed to making the trade-in process easy and transparent. Whether you’re a collector or just looking to clean out your old toys, we offer fair evaluations and fast transactions to ensure a smooth experience.

Flexible Payment Options for Your Trade-In
Choose the payment option that best suits you. Get cash on the spot, with 30% of your item’s current market value, or opt for store credit and receive 40%—a great way to reinvest in your collection with other finds at Out The Box.

Fair and Accurate Evaluations by Our Team
Our experienced team evaluates each item based on its condition, rarity, and popularity. This process ensures that we provide accurate and fair offers, giving you confidence that you’re getting the best value for your toys. Visit us in Colorado to see what your collection is worth today!

Please note: We buy on a case-by-case basis and sometimes cannot purchase every collection that comes in. As much as we’d like to, we set a budget each month and focus on items we can sell quickly. Some months, our budget is used up faster than others, so please call ahead to check if we’re currently buying. Thank you for your understanding.

Have a collection you'd like to trade? Send us a photo of your items below!

  • Submit
Your cart is empty
Search

Select Currency

{CC} - {CN}
Cancel